A shoe that looks right on a shelf still has to work on your feet. Start with the places you walk, the surfaces you encounter and the socks or insoles you normally wear. An elegant pair is only useful if you can actually wear it comfortably.
Check length, width and depth
Try both shoes on, because feet are not always the same size. Stand and walk around: your toes should have room rather than pressing against the end or top. NHS footwear guidance recommends enough length, width and depth and advises against relying on a painful shoe to become comfortable after breaking in. If you use prescribed insoles, take them when trying shoes.
Walk before deciding
Pay attention to heel movement, rubbing and how the fastening holds the foot. Try the shoes indoors on a clean surface and check the retailer’s return policy first. Shoe sizing differs across brands, so start with measurements and the individual size chart rather than assuming one number is universal.
Match the shoe to the day
A short dinner and a long commute place different demands on footwear. For persistent pain, changes in sensation or specific foot conditions, ask a qualified clinician for advice tailored to you. The most versatile shoe is the one that fits your feet and routine.